Home Talent TRANSFORM Teaser: Automation’s Impact on Jobs

TRANSFORM Teaser: Automation’s Impact on Jobs


James Bessen, Executive Director, Technology & Policy Research Initiative, Boston University, will lead a discussion at TRANSFORM on the challenge of ensuring that workers have the requisite tech skills in a rapidly changing economic and technologic landscape. For an advanced look at some of the topics that he will be addressing, read his article on automation and its impact on the labor market.

James Bessen, Boston University
James Bessen

Automation isn’t just for blue-collar workers anymore. Computers are now taking over tasks performed by professional workers, raising fears of massive unemployment. Some people, such as the MIT professors Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee, identify automation as a cause of the slow recovery from the Great Recession and the “hollowing out of the middle class.” Others see white-collar automation as causing a level of persistent technological unemployment that demands policies that would redistribute wealth. Robot panic is in full swing.

But these fears are misplaced—what’s happening with automation is not so simple or obvious. It turns out that workers will have greater employment opportunities if their occupation undergoes some degree of computer automation. As long as they can learn to use the new tools, automation will be their friend.

Take the legal industry as an example. Computers are taking over some of the work of lawyers and paralegals, and they’re doing a better job of it. For over a decade, computers have been used to sort through corporate documents to find those that are relevant to lawsuits. This process—called “discovery” in the profession—can run up millions of dollars in legal bills, but electronic methods can erase the vast majority of those costs. Moreover, the computers are often more accurate than humans: In one study, software correctly found 95 percent of the relevant documents, while humans identified only 51 percent

But, perhaps surprisingly, electronic discovery software has not thrown paralegals and lawyers into unemployment lines. In fact, employment for paralegals and lawyers has grown robustly. While electronic discovery software has become a billion-dollar business since the late 1990s, jobs for paralegals and legal-support workers actually grew faster than the labor force as a whole, adding over 50,000 jobs since 2000, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau. The number of lawyers increased by a quarter of a million.

Something similar happened when ATMs automated the tasks of bank tellers and when barcode scanners automated the work of cashiers: Rather than contributing to unemployment, the number of workers in these occupations grew.

These are not special exceptions. On average, since 1980, occupations with above-average computer use have grown substantially faster (0.9 percent per year), as shown in this chart:

The Average Annual Percentage Growth in Jobs Between 1980 and 2013

U.S. Census Bureau

How can this be? It might seem a sure thing that automating a task would reduce employment in an occupation. But that logic ignores some basic economics: Automation reduces the cost of a product or service, and lower prices tend to attract more customers. Software made it cheaper and faster to trawl through legal documents, so law firms searched more documents and judges allowed more and more-expansive discovery requests. Likewise, ATMs made it cheaper to operate bank branches, so banks dramatically increased their number of offices. So when demand increases enough in response to lower prices, employment goes up with automation, not down. And this is what has been happening with computer automation overall during the last three decades. It’s also what happened during the Industrial Revolution when automation in textiles, steel-making, and a whole range of other industries led to a major increase in manufacturing jobs.

But not all of the news about computer automation is good. Some of that growth in computer-using occupations has come at the expense of other occupations. As depicted in the chart below, desktop publishing systems have meant fewer jobs for typographers, as graphic designers took over their work. Computerized phone lines meant fewer jobs for telephone operators, but more jobs for receptionists. These aren’t examples of computers “stealing” jobs; they are cases where computers helped some workers take work from others. Workers with computers frequently substitute for workers in non-computerized jobs.

Number of Graphic-Design Jobs vs. Typographer Jobs, in Hundreds of Thousands

James Bessen; U.S. Census

So, while computers create jobs in some occupations, they also reduce employment in others. The total effect on unemployment depends on which tendency is stronger. Some of my research shows that the net effect, across the economy, is a wash: Computers create about as many jobs as they eliminate. In other words, automation is not causing persistent unemployment.

That could change decades into the future, as new generations of software powered by artificial intelligence becomes ever more capable of advanced tasks. But in the near term, the story is much different. A new study by McKinsey & Company took a detailed look at work tasks that are likely to be automated and found that only about 5 percent of jobs are at risk of being completely automated in the near future. The main effect of automation for the time being will not be to eliminate jobs, but to redefine them—changing the tasks and the skills needed to perform them.

Even so, this means that automation poses a major challenge. There will be jobs, but workers will only be able to get them if they have the new sets of skills that computers make important. It’s not just computer skills that are in demand, because automation can change the nature of jobs. For example, bank tellers have become more like marketing specialists, telling customers about bank loans, CDs, and other financial offerings.

Learning new skills is a significant social challenge as well. My research suggests that the jobs that get transferred to other occupations tend to be predominantly low-pay, low-skill jobs, so the burdens of automation fall most heavily on those least able and least equipped to deal with it. And often the new skills need to be learned on the job, so experience matters. To meet this challenge, some community colleges are collaborating with local employers to create work-study programs that allow trainees to learn on the job as well as in the classroom. Some trade groups are promoting skill-certification programs, which allow employers to recognize skills acquired through experience. These are the kinds of policies that can help overcome the real burden of automation. They deserve more attention than any panic about a supposed robot apocalypse.

Learn more at TRANSFORM about how to address the imperatives — an educated and inclusive workforce, secure data and systems, accountable transportation, sustainable environment — that will determine our future and economy.

exam: 100% Pass Guarantee 9L0-505 Training Guide Online, Passguide 350-050 Exam Guide Pdf For Sale, Examcollection E20-377 Exam Questions With The Knowledge And Skills, Certforall HSE-VIDEO Exam Collection Sale, 100% Success Rate GB0-180 Ebook For Sale, Reliable and Professional HP2-B120 Test Pdf On Store, Money Back Guarantee 000-917 Vce And Pdf Will Be More Popular, Best A2010-659 Self Study Guaranteed Success, First-hand C2090-551 Certification Answers On Store, Examcollection 00M-648 Pdf Download Is The Best Material, Testking P4070-005 Pdf Exam Online Sale, 100% Real GNSA Exam Demo For All Candidates From All Over The World, Sale Best 070-559 Actual Questions On Our Store, Experts Revised 070-536-CPLUSPLUS-CN Test Exam with PDF and VCE Engine, Sale Latest Release MB4-175 Prep Guide On Our Store, Provides Best 920-108 Certification Exam Online, Latest Release 920-161 Practice Exam Pdf Latest Version PDF&VCE, Test-inside GED-Reading Test Exam Is What You Need To Take, Provides 1Z1-211 Real Exam Questions With Accurate Answers, Topdump NSE4 Exam Test On Sale, Sale Best HP2-T16 Exam Prep For Download,

cbd oil: pure cbd gummies restorative botanicals cbd how cbd works cbd oil 50 mg shop cbd oil cbd beverage companies cbd therapeutics of wisconsin cbd retail store chill cbd oil cool diseases to do projects on where to buy cbd oil reddit cbd bath bomb 100mg does cbd shrink tumors pharmaceutical cbd how to use cbd oil for hair growth non psychoactive medical cannabis bulletproof cbd le pain nutrition cbd extraction services cbd t break 7 eleven locations melbourne cbd how to use cbd uncle buds hemp active ingredient in pot cannabidiol amazon pros and cons of hemp oil colitis define cbd hemp oil health benefits the potion terpenes for sale hope cbd oil define glucose metabolism most potent cbd oil what is the definition of find health benefits of cannabis oil so much potential or so we used to say can u get high off cbd chorea definition medical dictionary cbd illness california cbd oil laws 300mg cbd vape oil from verified sellers can you take coq10 with cbd oil at the same time you and us

cbd oil: difference between hemp oil and cbd oil entourage effect cbd in canada marijuana supplements cbd oil connecticut what is a cbd can i bring cbd on a plane high tech cbd oil healthy roots cbd cbd flu how to shop for cbd oil capsule sizes young living cbd oil price cbd and hiv perfume stores sydney cbd canna 9 cbd oil cbd oil before workout cbd plus melatonin much definition vape menu doterra customer service phone number penis enlargement pills amazon how to know w cbd oil ovarian cancer social interaction test mice how is that possible best weed for neuropathy third party results on green roads cbd oil buy bongs on amazon huge traduccion does cbd oil help arthritis pain 30 mg cbd elixir 15 ml cbd oil does blue cross blue shield cover cbd oil research impact is cbd oil illegal in utah treating cancer with cbd cbd oil utica ny cbd oil in topeka ks cbd oil drops use cbd infinite nicola murray cbd oil plus cbd oil capsules 15 mg

cbd oil: cbd oil with thc online does cbd oil give you gas cbd blogs terpene infused cbd cbd for plantar fasciitis cbd oil luverne minnesota cbd gummy bear cbd bubble bath elite cbd allergic reaction to cbd oil rash leafwize cbd oil cbd oil and vape kit innovet pet cbd benefits of cbd oil for cats vaping cbd vs oral can cbd help migraines what is cbd candy cbd college station onyx rose cbd oil hempworx oil homemade cbd salve cbd oil sunmed where to buy high quality cbd oil cbd clinical trials for chronic pain cbd feather flag doctor who alien list mcig cbd oil cbd oil private label the big sleep book summary cbd flower austin cb2 ny me power reviews best massage oil cvs does charlottes web cbd have thc cbd 77429 cbd shop online cbd oil for hemorrhagic stroke the scientific study of hair and its diseases and care vital plan cbd oil difference in pet and human cbd oil blue razzberry cbd oil cannabis deficiencies

cbd oil: cbd coupons codes cbd oil ogden utah cbd oil for menopause must do in sydney cbd quantum cbd water know out cbd oil at sprouts whats benefit cbd vape juice cheap pet cbd reviews does cbd really do anything where to buy cbd oil in newton 6000 mg cbd oil royal hunter rda cbd capsules 10mg bulk cbd hemp oil natural pure cbd oil holland and barrett cbd oil with thc vape when can i smoke weed after tooth extraction cbd fda approval cbd sublingual best pizza perth cbd cbd ac adapter physiological dose nervous system meme relief definition in science cbd childcare muscle relief oil liquid spectrum photography stoner stuff on amazon best hemp cbd sleep band merch cbd oil oahu most dangerous drugs diamind cbd essential oil recipe for diverticulitis hemp seeds for growing cbd cbd oil cartridge 510 is cbd oil legal in tennessee 2017 how to make healing oil with cbd what is the difference between cbd oil and hemp extract

weight loss: antidepressant weight loss weight loss clinic chula vista gastric sleeve weight loss by month super fast weight loss shark tank weight loss forskolin is boiled potato good for weight loss eft tapping weight loss is metformin used for weight loss big show weight loss 2017 plant based diet weight loss plan rick ross 2015 weight loss weight loss pills walmart weight loss 4 pills review topamax weight loss r lipoic acid weight loss healthy breakfasts for weight loss bee pollen weight loss pills weight loss hiram ga 7 keto reviews for weight loss wayde king weight loss 40 lb weight loss before and after glucomannan weight loss pills chaz bono weight loss challenge 3010 weight loss reviews dulcolax weight loss stories vegan foods for weight loss determine weight loss pills weight loss yoga poses can you buy weight loss pills under 18 best fat burning diet pills review diet pills good vitamin to lose weight vinegar pills to lose weight best weight loss shows new prescription diet pill diet pills the celebrities use reviews on forskolin prescription energy pills where can i buy ace diet pill garcinia cambogia and weight loss vigrx ingredients biblical weight loss secret

weight loss: chia seed and weight loss skinny weight loss tea jump rope for weight loss fasted cardio for weight loss dr phil wife weight loss ariel winters weight loss diabetic diet for weight loss meltdown diet pills cat sudden weight loss fitwatch weight loss calculator best fitness tracker for weight loss weight loss rx weight loss tattoo ideas sardine diet weight loss estarylla weight loss horizon weight loss kentucky weight loss center charlotte nc quick weight loss clinics in atlanta metamucil benefits weight loss clk weight loss pills reviews pre workout shake for weight loss water pills diet hugo hurley reyes weight loss weight loss slogans meal portions for weight loss chlorella for weight loss diabetic weight loss program dash diet weight loss supplements to help weight loss how to loss weight phenq weight loss pills best healthy diet plan for weight loss reviews of weight loss pills braggs apple cider vinegar weight loss best over the counter diet pills 2017 cla weight loss pills reviews top rated diet pills that work graves disease weight loss dash diet weight loss solution book interval weight loss dash diet meal plan for weight loss lap band weight loss surgery

weight loss: celine dion weight loss photos power foods for weight loss mike and molly weight loss ephedrine diet pills gnc albolene cream for weight loss mag 07 weight loss results jump rope weight loss before and after diet pills oxyelite pro average weight loss insanity newest diet pills that work meal kits for weight loss weight loss portion control homemade protein shakes for weight loss colon cleanse weight loss weight loss in newborn weight loss pills reviews 2016 pioneer valley weight loss weight loss with water pills dr oz weight loss forskolin gestational diabetes weight loss dwight howard weight loss chia seed weight loss before and after kettlebell weight loss results best weight loss blogs boogie2988 weight loss 2019 melissa o neil weight loss legit weight loss pills soy and menopause weight loss how to take vinegar for weight loss weight loss run weight loss pills with best results weight loss planner calculator hd weight loss pills gnc where to buy slimina diet pills caffeine diet pills that work advocare 24 day challenge weight loss diet pills and exercise otc water pill atkins diet weight loss rate fish oil weight loss results carb free diet plan for weight loss reviews on rapid tone weight loss

weight loss: oil for weight loss 7 slim diet pills weight loss printables 15 pound weight loss icd 10 code for unexplained weight loss diet pills that contain phentermine best wii workout games for weight loss omni weight loss diet plan jontron weight loss what kind of pills are these coconut water for weight loss is premier protein good for weight loss red light therapy weight loss reviews almonds good for weight loss guthrie weight loss fast and easy weight loss cambogia weight loss pill boiled plantain for weight loss precious new weight loss easy normal diet pills can lisinopril cause weight loss total life changes weight loss medical weight loss hours weight loss rx medication 4 week weight loss before and after steak and eggs diet weight loss moore weight loss clinic valley medical weight loss homeopathy weight loss pills how to measure yourself for weight loss depakote and weight loss pills 1700 calorie meal plans for weight loss quisma diet pills infared weight loss phenomenon diet pills high pills diet pills boots weight loss industry stats buy preludin diet pills foods that cause weight loss strong diet for weight loss advocare weight loss results

male enhancement: cardura generic name nutrigenix reviews penis lengthening exercises average penis size usa penile enlargement cost does extenz work what is the average erect penile size penile enlargment penis enlargement before after how to make natural viagra at home normal penis length penis size average photos of male penises naturally boosting testosterone footlong penis turmeric and erectile dysfunction vitamins for seniors over 70 testosterone stack rhodiola rosea for ed std tests walmart natural nitric oxide booster red viagra him hair products male enhancement exercises youtube alpha male testosterone booster penis strengthening exercises cheapest tablets at walmart how to get more girth fast vigrx plus official website definition of dysfunction erect uncircumcised average penis size before puberty long lasting sex best pills to keep you hard best weight loss pills for men vitamins store vasoplexx results new pill for ed stuff to make your dick bigger tv 150 pill street price male enhancement sergury male extra side effects

male enhancement: cures for erectile dysfunction what penis size is considered small viagra street value drugs to get her in the mood erectile dysfunction problems is my penis large using viagra without ed masturbation tips men do dick pumps really work best ed pills non prescription how to grow ur penis my big penis urologist penile enlargement testosterone food boosters extreme penis pump what is the effect of viagra can you buy testosterone potato penis best herbal testosterone booster best food for libido doctor recommended testosterone booster extends ingredients best supplements for ed best supplements for male enhancement pills volume herbal alternative to viagra yohimbe blood pressure magic mike pills review impotence symptoms penis enlargement hypnosis why morning erection marley generics viagra super long penis penis bigger 5 in dick testosterone suppliment beautiful penis pictures girls growing dicks wood pills average 15 year old penile length viapro herbal gmc nutrition

male enhancement: how to get in the mood for my husband twenty one pil ways to improve sexual stamina increase pennis size naturally viagra vs levitra male enhancement pills near me erection aids that work two penis condition viagra grapefruit penis clothing 13 in cock do testicles produce testosterone strooming and extending exercises cialis not covered by insurance mens erect penis estrogen blocker reviews walmart male enhancement pills cialis hearing loss premier zen pills reviews hard erection tips blue pill with a on it niacin for weed viagra reaction time wiki penis size pills and vitamins for sexual performance vitamins for erections home remedies for ed how does yohimbe work steel rx scam best foods for erectile strength penis hangers finasteride results timeline endovex pills whats the biggest dick in the world how to jelq sex defintion ultimate males testosterone boosting recipes vigrx pills boosting testosterone foods paravex male enhancement formula

male enhancement: alternative for viagra does weight loss increase penis size what is the main ingredient in viagra herbs to increase sex drive what is male enhancement male enhancement leads penis enlargemnt best nitric oxide foods penis inch aberage penis size top 5 testosterone boosters how to make penis strong surgical prices ways to make your pennis bigger watch sex drive online free male enhancement cream walmart watch sex drive online cialis next day delivery usa huge limp dick sex stamina tips other sex long does take steel libido work partial erections lump inside penile shaft hims hair promo code priapus shot webmd 8 inches dick free penis testo max for sale pennies sex the man with no penis low blood pressure erectile dysfunction bleeding from the penis men hair png big penis picture last nite tabs testosterone pills for working out dick clamping penil pump does progentra work male enhancement xl reviews best supplement for low testosterone

vape: good vape starter kits harmfulness of vaping mods vape one milpitas best dry herb vape reddit new coils for vape atmos jump amazon high5 enail e cigarette store ithaca ny lonestar vapor smok t14 coil buy vapes ecig products cheap vapor best ipv mod time bomb vape juice uwell valyrian coils review what makes vape juice sweet e cigarette case 510 can you bring e cigarette in seaworld best vape pens 2014 hooka e cigarette nicotine free melon where can i get vape pens does vaping nic salt upset your stomach open vape cartridges denver voopoo drag battery vape shops in idaho falls best vape to start with vapor rub liquid e juice wax vape pen review coil cost smok mag coil smok m2 temperature control ecig express coupon code 2015 v12 smok tank ecig and baby voopoo vfl covers rocky top vapor kingsport tn why does my voopoo drag have a weak drag alien 220w short atomizer how to switch from wattage to degree on voopoo mojo original e cigarette

vape: freemax vape website best organic vape juice diamond vape shop how long does a blu e cigarette last best nicotine free vape getting vape juice in mouth gettysburg vape vape pen flashing e vapor kit can drug dogs smell vape vg ecig liquid black ecig mod ecig store uk do i need to keep vape upright megatron penis mod ecig a10 ecig box 60 mg vape juice vaping bad for health cosmic fog nutz smok nord lname e cigarette lobby coupon vuse alto vape articles about vaping how to add nicotine to vape juice texas vaping laws difference between sub ohm vaping alien baby kit smok nord blinking 4 times mini istick vaporizer parts of a e cigarette clocc coil vape shops in albuquerque rba crown uwell voopoo 200w uwell crown o ring drip tip how does wattage affect vaping uwell crown vs triton baby drag priming uwell crown v2 coils tfv12 prince q4 coils how to set atomizer on voopoo drag smok al85 replacement coils

vape: vape usa how many reported deaths from vaping uwell amulet snowwolf 200w vs voopoo drag ego twist vape 213 vape vape shop indianapolis ecig classified vape shop pittsburgh smok alien kit gunmetal i vape albany just vape la lucky turtle lux 200 coilart prodigy ecig smok novo price ecig eleaf voopoo drag custom battery door coffee flavor vape juice cloud coils my vape is spitting juice smok prince tank reviews nicotine salts health vaping deaths cause how to prime tfv4 coils nano vape mod revenger mod smok osub tank cotton candy vape wick salt vape juice flavors vape pen plus smok vape shop columbus ga smok prince resa can i have a ecig in my carry on uwell caliburn pod vape bash voopoo baby drag vaping damage how to change voopoo drag back to watts e cigarette allergies voopoo too tank review zero vaporesso

vape: trump vaping sourin juice vape popping cheap vape pens ebay vape shop in brooklyn cigarette vs e cig price vape pen not heating vapor retarder paint headbanger vape tesla ecigs skittles vape cue vapor flavors fuel vapor 20x9 making a vape pen jet2 e cigarette wax vape pen attachment vaping in the hood vape ohm chart effects of vaping on your lungs smok species v2 kit crown 4 kit replacement glass for tfv8 juul competitor volcano ecig kiosk wismec reuleaux rx mini black sticky substance from ecig red box mods best budget sub ohm tank vape building coils aspire zelos review ego aio wont charge aurora play vaporesso smok sub ohm mod vape juice without formaldehyde crown rta uwell black and mild vape juice how to clean uwell crown tank violet vapor uwell tank rebuildable coil best vape starter kit for cbd oil voopoo too how to start how much nicotine is in a cigarette percentage